Thanks a lot! It's too bad the only fish at Petco are Gold Fish and the Rosy Red Minnows so they're no good, I have to find a new fish source. They also have worms, but they were out of nightcrawlers so I just bought him 1 pinkie for his mid-week snack.

I'm definitely starting to think Matt is a girl, I'll post pictures soon.

The nightcrawlers come in packs of 20, is that too many/not enough for one feeding?

Thanks for all the help!